Welcome to Mister Sub
Mister Sub is a beloved local sub shop located in Chillicothe, Ohio, that combines quality ingredients with a homely atmosphere. Renowned for its exceptional bread, Mister Sub is celebrated for hearty options like the signature meatball and Italian subs, reminiscent of East Coast flavors. Whether you're dining in, getting takeout, or enjoying a meal with family and friends, the inviting space and friendly service make it a favorite among locals. The shop's casual vibe, along with its accessible delivery and takeout options, ensures that enjoying a delicious sub is always a convenient choice.
Mister Sub: Reviews & Ratings
Favorite sub place!! Amazing bread!! My go to is the garbage sub always a 16 in and their meatball subs are so yummy. Always order at the firehouse!
Good food good service good time nice atmosphere clean bathrooms big parking mountain dew products
If you're looking for a non-chain sub-shop, this is your pick. Other reviews can regale you with their selections, but for me, it's the meatball sub, which reminds me of the grinders I've gotten on the East Coast. The sauce is perfect, and the meatballs are delicious, but the bread steals the show. My wife opts for the Italian Sub and loves it every time. I've also got a good Philly sub here. There is no cheese whiz, but it's close to the recipe. Inside the place is nothing to write home about. One big drawback: You might miss the place because the owner hasn't changed the sign, which says "The Mill pizza" out front. It gives the impression that it's not open, or about the close. It was acceptable for a few months, but after years, it's time to invest the sign, my guy.
Just stopped on our way through town at this spot. Thought it was more of a sub/deli sandwich spot but seemed like a pizza place that does subs, which wasn't a bad thing. You order at the counter so not really service to mention, but no complaints. Plenty of seats and most people looked to be locals on lunch which isn't a bad thing in my book. The meatball sub was actually pretty darn good! I added pepperoni to it and trust me on that move, well worth it. Good size and nice crunchy bread too. Wouldn't go out of my way or anything, but I enjoyed it and was a good lunch while on our road trip. I try not to each nationwide chains and support local when I can..
The food is pretty good service was great also the ambiance is also pretty good. I would definitely recommend
We were curious what was on the menu but couldn't find one online so we stopped by and took these photos to save others from the same problem. As soon as I opened the door I was surrounded by the delicious scent of Italian subs. Instant mouth watering. The staff were incredibly friendly and helpful. We ordered the super Italian sub and chicken bacon ranch (CBR) sub. The CBR was good, but kind of one-note in texture and flavor. I had asked for pickles but was told that the only pickles they offered were spears. Luckily, I had some Jimmy John's peppers in the fridge, so I added those and voila! so much better, delicious in fact! The real star of the night was the super Italian sub. It was so good that our family who came to visit later in the evening took our suggestion and stopped by to get some as well. We will definitely return for the super Italian sub, and if they decide to start offering dill pickle slices, I would gladly order more subs as well.
The bread for the subs is awesome- I did the Italian w/ everything and this is now a date night dinner spot because sweety loved the ham and cheese Solid 5 stars And don't forget the cannolis!! : excellent meal overall
Location
-
543 E Main St Chillicothe, OH 45601 Hotline: (740) 774-7827
If you're searching for a unique sub shop experience that stands apart from the well-trodden chains, look no further than Mister Sub, located at 543 E Main St, Chillicothe, OH. This local gem crafts sandwiches that resonate with flavor and character, much to the delight of its devoted patrons.
Mister Sub is not just about providing a meal; it is about creating an experience. Offering a variety of utilities, including delivery and takeout services, the shop is perfect for group gatherings and family outings, and it conveniently features TV and Wi-Fi for those who want to stay connected while enjoying their meal. With a bright atmosphere and a friendly service, it caters to locals and passing travelers alike.
Now, let’s talk about the food. The highlight of Mister Sub lies in its incredible bread, which diners rave about. Reviews consistently mention the standout meatball sub, praised for its perfectly seasoned meatballs and rich sauce. One satisfied customer exclaimed how it reminded him of the authentic grinders found on the East Coast, where the flavor profiles are rich and the portions hearty. The garbage sub, loaded with a delightful mix, and the Italian sub, beloved by loyal patrons, further exemplify the artistry behind Mister Sub’s offerings.
- Customer Favorites:
- Meatball Sub – A must-try with its homemade sauce and perfectly baked bread.
- Garbage Sub – An extravagant choice for those seeking variety in every bite.
- Italian Sub – The perfect option for those craving classic flavors.
- Atmosphere: Local vibe, casual dining, family-friendly.
- Services: Offers delivery, takeout, good for groups and kids.
Though the ambiance may not be anything overly extravagant, patrons enjoy the warmth and cleanliness of the establishment, which feels welcoming and community-driven. With an option for those who prefer to support local establishments, Mister Sub proves to be a worthwhile stop, as echoed by visitors who appreciate its authenticity amidst a sea of fast-food chains.
In conclusion, whether you’re a local or just passing through, Mister Sub offers a delightful escape into the world of savory sandwiches. From the flavorful fillings to the star of the show—its incredible bread—this sub shop eclipses the mediocrity of chain eateries. Feel free to drop by or give them a call at (740) 774-7827 to curate a meal you won’t soon forget!
